Power-to-Gas in Microgrids: Competitive with Batteries?

Share Button

Power-to-gas, a technology that converts excess renewable energy to gases that can be stored, is cost-competitive with lithium-ion batteries in microgrids, according to Matt Gregori, technology development manager, Southern California Gas.

Gregori spoke at a solar conference last week at the University of California, Riverside.

power-to-gas

Batteries at UC Riverside

Southern California Gas recently conducted a computer simulation of using power-to-gas in an existing microgrid at University of California Irvine (UCI), and concluded that the amount of renewable energy used could jump from 3.5 percent to 35 percent, Gregori said.

In addition, researchers at University of California in Irvine created a sophisticated financial model comparing power-to-gas to lithium-ion batteries.

“They found that power-to-gas, using a natural gas pipeline, is cost effective with lithium-ion batteries,” he said. It’s especially cost-competitive for longer charging durations, he noted.

The UCI microgrid has a central plant with combined-cycle turbines, chillers, thermal energy storage and some solar. “It’s an interesting test bed for new technology to support microgrid applications,” he said at the conference, “Solar Power: Past, Present and its Future in Inland Southern California.” He was one of three speakers on a panel about microgrids.

The UCI demonstration included a 60-kW proton on-site electrolyzer, and on-campus pipeline blending, he noted.

“Batteries are good at shifting from day to night, but if you store energy for a week or month, the round trip efficiency falls apart,” he said. “We think power-to-gas can be cost competitive, particularly for long-term storage,” he said. Gases created from power-to-gas can be stored in pipelines, he said.

“Power to gas is the opposite of gas-to-power. This is taking power and using it to create renewable natural gas,” he explained during a panel about microgrids.

Solar paves the way for power-to-gas

Power-to-gas makes sense especially in California, where 99 percent of planned renewable projects are solar.

power-to-gas

U.S. Dept. of Energy

“There’s all this solar power coming on the grid during the day; I’m sure you’ve seen the duck curve. We have a tremendous amount of excess renewable electricity. The concept is to take excess and convert it to gaseous fuel, hydrogen or methane. You can store it in above-ground tanks or in a pipeline system and use it later at a higher value,” Gregori said.

The seasonal nature of solar production, especially in California, creates an opportunity for power-to-gas, he noted. While there is lots of solar produced in the spring, when it’s sunny and cool, it isn’t always used because consumers and businesses haven’t turned on their air conditioners. In summer, however, the demand jumps with the hot temperatures and increased use of air conditioning.

“Power to gas allows for long-term seasonal energy storage; instead of shifting from day to night, it can shift from March to August,” he said.

Free Resource from Microgrid Knowledge White Paper Library

How Microgrids Enable Optimal Cooperation Among Distributed Energy Resources
Many facility operators need increased resiliency, efficiently, and sustainability. Distributed Energy Resources (DERs) like wind, PV and energy storage can address these needs. Yet also introduce many other challenges. To learn how microgrids can help you optimize the integration of these assets, download this white paper.

Southern California Gas’s pipeline system has about 13 tWh of equivalent electricity storage, he noted. Building battery storage facilities with the same amount of storage capacity would cost about $2.6 trillion.

‘That’s the cost of replacing a natural gas pipeline already available,” Gregori said.

Power-to-gas is currently not considered an eligible storage technology under the CPUC’s energy storage procurement mandate which requires state investor-owned utilities to procure 1.3 GW of storage by 2020, he noted.

How battery prices affect microgrids

Also at the conference, the microgrid panel participants identified the major challenges to moving the microgrid industry forward.

Chris Linn, project manager, Smarter Grid Solutions, said that the cost of batteries is a major challenge. “With decreasing battery costs, there will be more opportunities to create microgrids because there’s enough on a line segment or circuit to be self-sustaining.”

Eric Bakke, project development executive, EnSync Energy Systems, agreed that prices are the biggest challenge. “Once the price of energy storage gets down to $200/kWh, and energy generated by solar decreases to 8 cents/kWh at the residential level, pretty much everyone will have production, storage and resilience,” he said.

The complexity of the grid system is the biggest challenge, said Gregori. “As we see more distributed energy deployed, there are complicated energy markets. Looking at power-to-gas, we’re overwhelmed by who will buy grid services. I’d like to meet the people who are building algorithms and software to manage it; that will be critical,” he said.

Join us for the microgrid event of the year, Microgrid 2018, May 7-9 in Chicago.

Share Button

Sign up for our newsletter and get the latest microgrid news and analysis.

Comments

  1. Nicanor F. Panganiban says:

    How it converts the Power to Gas? Please explain well in a layman’s understanding and the operating principle of it in converting Power to Gas.

    Thanks.

    Nick

  2. The Most exciting thing about Hydrogen is that we can create a valid roi business for investors who already own power producing assets .
    The Number one thing we address from a business income point of view,
    is we take you lost wasted and unsold, curtail power product that
    you produce and waste and save it we turn it into a new Product with new invoices Called

    Hydrogen and Hydrogen Distribution, this fixed several items and create money from from
    stranded or unsold power per. Hour. Currently delivered Hydrogen from Carbon Based Resources
    ( brown h2) is 16.80 $usd or aprox 14 Euro per kg of gas not including transport and an additional taxes.
    deliver it is common to see 19 to 25 USD /Euro kg , So if we Present which we do the Global Community

    business Model of making renewable Green Hydrogen Certified from Renewable sites using wind geothermal hydro or solar,.
    Basing it on there cost per kw to sell power to them selves or use their spinning reserve wasted power per hour we are in the cost
    of production on power 0.002 cents per kw to 0.30 cents per kw. + water and roi. We can Wholesale out that gas including taxed
    7 to 10 Per kg Retailer can add their margin plus logistics. I hope this helps, Hydrogen can be held on site to time shift
    power to sell power latter in evening or meet load commitments, most most importantly if held on site it can secure the

    PPA contract and power production from Failure to supply, Meaning We have Prime power Back up fuel by Hydrogen on site so you
    fill to meet the hrs back you want to run and all the rest of the gas made is distributed out out sold to pecker plants or hubs
    users or industry at a new income new invoices which are not dependent on the Power gid ppa, we make a New thing Called a GPA Gas
    purchase agreement it give a parallel income and back up it sells spinning reserve power which is per hr loss 5 to 20% at most wind
    farms and hydro which spin 24 hr. We do not have to focus on just pumps sales pump sales are important but there is a ready well
    establish buying daily market for green H2 and developing and switching diesels to run on h2 is what we do at Secure Supplies.

    If you are interested in broadening the H2 Products Offerings you have to include Green H2
    and empower your sustainability programs you have

    I am interested in a JV Strategic partnership on projects to develop your resource further I am a Contractor Partner
    Design Developer.

    Daniel Donatelli
    Fouder
    Secure Supplies
    danieldonatelli1@gmail.com
    whatsapp + 66 83 6473 443

  3. Kevin O'Halloran says:

    The concept of converting excess electricity to hydrogen gas is already being done in Europe. They hydrogen can be converted directly to electricity via a fuel cell or it is bled into their natural gas system at a low level.

  4. Sarpong Hammond Antwi says:

    This is a refreshing news regarding the various challenges in storing excess energy. However i think more awareness and publicity should go into this new technology. Recently, we had a debate with a professor and he pointed out that soon an emerging technology was to emerge in storing electricity generated from renewable. I am glad hearing this breakthrough

  5. Interesting! I hope to see this happen in the future!

Trackbacks

  1. […] Power-to-Gas in Microgrids: Competitive with Batteries? […]

Leave a Comment

*