A Surprise to Analysts: Less CHP in Microgrids, More Solar

Share Button

Combined heat and power (CHP) provides year-round baseload energy in microgrids — something renewable resources don’t do. Yet solar PV now overshadows CHP in planned microgrid projects, according to a new microgrid database by ICF.

“We see a lot of installed CHP systems in operating microgrids; it’s the largest technology in terms of capacity,” said David Jones, ICF’s manager and analyst for CHP/DER/microgrid markets and applications. “We were surprised to not see as much CHP in the planned microgrids.”

The reason? Microgrid developers are moving away from fossil fuels, Jones said. Instead, they’re installing solar and energy storage. Or others choose simpler, power-only natural gas generation, as opposed to CHP.

microgrids

Courtesy of ICF 

Cost might be a factor, said Jones. It’s possible those who are developing microgrid projects think CHP is too expensive to incorporate.

CHP is a resource that ICF carefully follows — it has been updating the Department of Energy’s CHP Installation Database for over a decade.

The shift to solar is occuring despite the efficiency CHP affords. Used for more than a century, CHP uses the heat byproduct created during the generation of electricity. Its used to warm buildings, create cooling, produce steam or serve other processes that require thermal energy. In contrast, conventional generators waste the byproduct, letting it waft into the air or water.

In all, the database identifies about 400 MW of planned solar PV, compared with about 200 MW of CHP for microgrid projects. However, because CHP operates 24 hours a day, it dominates based on operating capacity, Jones noted.  

Community model rising fastest

ICF created the microgrid database because of the industry’s’ growth.

“Microgrids have really started to gain momentum,” he said.

The consulating firm identified 211 operational microgrids in the US that yield 3.85 GW of capacity and 104 in planning that could produce 1.55 GW of capacity, when installed. Most — both operational and planned — can be found in the Northeast, with a large number also planned for California, Hawaii and Alaska.

The database also found that community microgrids represent the fastest growing type of ownership model. That’s partially due to the NY Prize and other state incentives, including those offered by Massachusetts, New Jersey and Connecticut.

“The community microgrids have more planned capacity compared to any of the other ownership types,” said Jones.

ICF

Courtesy of ICF 

Utilities getting into the game

ICF also found more projects now being planned and developed by end users, as opposed to utilities. However, that’s starting to change.

Free Resource from Microgrid Knowledge White Paper Library

How to Optimize Energy Storage in a Microgrid
In this paper, new voltage sensitivity indexes are proposed to search and evaluate the candidate buses in a microgrid, where the energy storage systems can be installed to contribute most effectively to the system. To learn more about optimized energy storage in a microgrid download this white paper.

“We’re seeing a lot more microgrids in the planning process owned by utilities or having mixed ownership with their utility and third parties,” said Jones. “It’s because utilities are starting to realize the benefits microgrids can provide to the grid.”

In addition, utilities don’t want to lose their customers, he said. Installing microgrids helps utilities keep customers that might otherwise defect in favor of installing their own systems.

“Utilities can offer reliability with local microgrids and keep customers and continue to serve them,” he said.

Storms and microgrids

The need for energy resiliency and reliability drives microgrid growth more than any other factor, according to Jones. 

“One of the big draws of microgrids is they are able to produce their own power during an outage, and we expect that to grow,” he said.

Extreme weather in the Northeast, plus incentives, have prompted the additions, Jones said. On the West Coast, renewable energy policy has led to more planned microgrids in California.

Given the recent hurricanes, Jones sees the need for energy resiliency driving microgrid growth, with state and federal governments offering more incentives for microgrids at critical facilities.

Join us to discuss the latest microgrid trends at Microgrid 2019: Reshaping the Electric Grid, May 14-16 in San Diego.

Feature photo courtesy of By Ultrashock/Shutterstock.com.

Share Button

Sign up for our newsletter and get the latest microgrid news and analysis.

Comments

  1. Brent Grotz says:

    Very good article, two main points overlooked:

    1- Renewable s- Solar and Fuel Cells, are getting the lion share of the Incentive Programs (ROI), self-generation CHP genset’s barely qualify for incentives with Biogas, and essentially no funding incentives for Natural Gas genset’s .
    2- CHP generation does not qualify as ‘Emergency Backup Energy’, as would a Diesel genset (startup and load within seconds vs minutes for CHP genset), due to load handling characteristics.

Leave a Comment

*