Bracing for Multiple-Day Outages, Another California City Advances Microgrid Project

Share Button

Another California community is moving ahead with a microgrid project, this one the city of Camarillo, which plans microgrids at five key city facilities in a move aimed at bolstering reliability while lowering electricity costs.

Aerial view of coastal farm fields near Oxnard and Camarillo in scenic Ventura County, California. By trekandshoot/Shutterstock.com

Four of the projects include backup diesel generators coupled with solar and battery storage. One project  includes only solar and storage. Combined, the projects include about 4 MW of solar, 4.2 MWh of storage, 500 kW of new diesel capacity to go with 1.4 MW of existing diesel at a cost of $13 million.

The sites are city hall, a police station, a wastewater treatment plant, a library and the public work’s yard.

The solar+storage systems will keep the sites online during outages that last up to two hours, with the diesel generators onhand for extended outages, according to the Clean Coalition, a non-profit that conducted a feasibility study for the city.

“The study made it clear that hybrid solar microgrids are not only feasible but also economically viable,” Greg Ramirez, Camarillo city manager, said. “Implementing these cost-effective hybrid solutions represents a big step toward meeting both city and regional sustainability goals.”

Camarillo is one of many

Camarillo is one of several government entities in California pursuing microgrid projects, a trend driven by wildfire-related power shutoffs, sustainability goals and a desire to lower energy costs. Santa Barbara is installing six microgrids for its school. McKinleyville is building a $2 million microgrid at a wastewater treatment plant in a contract with Ameresco. The Metropolitan Water District of Southern California plans to build microgrids at three water treatment plants and a pumping station. Sonoma Valley Unified School District has a unique front-of-the-meter microgrid project underway. They are among several California cities, tribal entities and school districts in various stages of microgrid development.

A city of 65,000 near Los Angeles, Camarillo in early 2018 began exploring adding diesel generators at three of the facilities with an eye on boosting reliability at critical facilities. The city’s police station and wastewater treatment plant already had backup diesel units.

Join us for a special virtual session: “Wind, Waves, Wildfire: How Microgrids Serve in a Time of Climate Crisis,” at Microgrid 2020 Global, Nov. 17-19. Conference registration is free but will close November 16 or when the platform cap is reached. So we urge you to register now.

However, in mid-2019, the city council decided to see if solar and battery storage could be used at the five sites as an alternative to the diesel generators.

In the last five years, the longest outage at one of the facilities lasted 21 hours and the second longest outage was about five hours, Camarillo city staff said Oct. 28 at a meeting when the city council voted to move forward with the projects.  

Overall, there were 53 outages that lasted an hour on average. Staff said future outages will likely be longer, potentially up to days because of wildfires, floods, earthquakes and planned utility public safety shutoffs.

The Clean Coalition estimates the microgrids will reduce greenhouse gas emissions from the five sites by about 88%.

Free Resource from Microgrid Knowledge Library

Nanogrids: A New Opportunity for the Solar Industry
Solar energy has the ability to provide immense benefit to society and the grid. But solar’s full potential isn’t being fully realized. Get the new report designed to help boost awareness and understanding of solar nanogrids, courtesy of Instant ON.
We always respect your privacy and we never sell or rent our list to third parties. By downloading this White Paper you are agreeing to our terms of service. You can opt out at any time.

Get this PDF emailed to you.

Over the 30-year life of the projects, the microgrids are expected to achieve zero net energy and yield utility bill savings through reduced demand and energy charges, the Clean Coalition said. The savings will depend on which financing option the city chooses: a city-owned model or a power purchase agreement, according to the organization.

The solar systems were sized to provide 150% of average daily load. The wastewater treatment plant, for example, would have 2.6 MW of solar and 2.25 MWh of battery storage to go with its existing diesel generator. The infrastructure would cost about $7.7 million, according to the Clean Coalition.

Possible FEMA funding for microgrid project

Looking ahead, the city council will have to decide if the city should pay for and own the microgrids itself or use a power purchase agreement model.

Generally, the PPA model would be less expensive for the city, partly because the city cannot take advantage of federal investment tax credits for the facilities.

However, the city plans to apply for a grant from FEMA that could cover up to 75% of the project’s capital cost.

The council directed city staff to pursue the grant from FEMA, which in August announced a $500 million grant program for infrastructure like microgrids that can reduce disaster risks. 

FEMA is expected to announce grant winners next summer, according to city staff.

The city may seek to take advantage of other grant opportunities as well.

City staff is slated to return to the city council in November with more refined cost estimates for the microgrid projects. 

Got a microgrid project underway? Tell us about it on LinkedIn. Check out our group, Microgrid Knowledge.

Share Button

Sign up for our newsletter and get the latest microgrid news and analysis.

Comments

  1. Beware, if and when fuel prices go back up, you will quickly find these diesel powered generators will be fuel thieves favorite targets. If the site has telemetry on the generator set, it will most likely show up as a low fuel alarm.
    The other problems with rarely used assets is having to automatic test each unit at least once a week, this may or may not upset any neighbors to the plants. Rodents, wasps, bees can find refuge in these assets and will create a health hazard to anyone on site, when it fires up. IF one can get away with solar PV and ESS, it would be a better option in the long run.

  2. How about more vertical axis wind turbines and generators that run off of natural gas or propane?

  3. “City staff is slated to return to the city council in November with more refined cost estimates for the microgrid projects. ”

    As the supposed “hardening” of the grid continues and utilities using the PSPS to help keep wildfires to a minimum are used, the hit to the local economy will sooner or later drive cities and maybe even counties into solar PV farms with energy storage for the bulk of their energy needs. CCAs will begin to become the electricity arbitrators of the future, distancing themselves from the utility and its infrastructure. The utility death spiral continues on.

Leave a Comment

*