Non-Wires Alternatives Embraced by BPA as it Abandons 80-mile Transmission Line Project

Share Button

The Bonneville Power Administration plans to pursue non-wires alternatives instead of an 80-mile transmission line, signaling a business shift toward targeted solutions over large centralized infrastructure.

non-wires alternatives

The first 10 miles of the McNary-John Day Transmission Line by Highway 10 in Washington State

“The outcome is much bigger than a decision to build or not build this line: We are transforming how we plan for and manage our transmission system and commercial business practices regionwide,” said Elliot Mainzer, BPA administrator, in announcing cancellation of the I-5 Corridor Reinforcement Project.

Non-wires alternatives solve congestion problems with targeted and often local energy solutions, like microgrids and virtual power plants, using advanced software intelligence with distributed generation, energy storage, demand response, and other forms of alternative energy.

Large transmission projects have faced fervent opposition by nearby property owners and activists in recent years; non-wires alternatives offer a less visually obtrusive way to maintain electric reliability.

BPA said that the decision reflects its commitment to a new “more flexible, scalable, and economically and operationally efficient approach to managing reliability.”

Proposed in 2009, the 500-kV line would have run from Castle Rock, Washington, to Troutdale, Oregon. Facing public opposition and rising costs, BPA analyzed the project again, looking at its economics, planning assumptions and commercial practices, along with findings of regional utilities and independent industry experts.

Now, instead of building the transmission line, the federal power agency plans to pursue a two-year, non-wires alternative pilot to relieve congestion in the greater Portland-Vancouver area during summer peaks. BPA hopes to achieve 100 MW of flow relief along the most congested portion of the transmission corridor for four-hour blocks.

BPA also will pursue congestion relief by identifying upgrades to existing transmission infrastructure and updating business and commercial practices.

The decision to use non-wires alternatives won praise from Fred Heutte, senior policy associate for the NW Energy Coalition.

“After looking carefully at all the options, it turns out that a combination of methods relying on clean energy and optimizing power plant generation is a better and less costly choice.  The new power line would have cost over a billion dollars, putting a major burden on communities and property owners in southwest Washington and electric bill payers across the Northwest,” he said.

BPA plans to convene a technical conference within a month to discuss its new approach to managing grid congestion.

A non-profit agency, BPA provides about 28 percent of the electric power used in the Northwest, most of it from hydroelectricity.  BPA’s territory includes Idaho, Oregon, Washington, western Montana and small parts of eastern Montana, California, Nevada, Utah and Wyoming.

Free Resource from Microgrid Knowledge White Paper Library

utility microgrids
Dawn of the Utility Microgrid: The Path to a Profitable Future
So how can utilities continue to fulfill their service reliability obligations of today, while also integrating the distributed energy and up-and-coming technologies of tomorrow? Download the new white paper from Siemens and learn more about how today's utilities are beginning to prepare by entering discussions around grid modernization, DER compensation, and business model transformation, by sharply enhancing core utility priorities, such as reliability, resiliency, and efficiency.

Track news about non-wires alternatives by becoming a Microgrid Knowledge subscriber. It’s free.

Share Button

Sign up for our newsletter and get the latest microgrid news and analysis.
Elisa Wood About Elisa Wood

Elisa Wood is the chief editor of She has been writing about energy for more than two decades for top industry publications. Her work also has been picked up by CNN, the New York Times, Reuters, the Wall Street Journal Online and the Washington Post.


  1. […] organization embracing non-wires alternatives is the Bonneville Power Administration (BPA), which says this option has begun to transform how the federal agency plans and manages its […]

Leave a Comment