Syracuse Microgrid Forecasts Positive Return Leveraging Waste-to-Energy

The Syracuse microgrid, one of 11 NY Prize Stage 2 winners, is forecasting a strong financial return using waste-to-energy generation that eases pressure on local landfills.

Led by the Central NY Regional Planning and Development Board (CNYRPDB), the project is the only Stage 2 winner to rely on waste-to-energy conversion as its primary distributed generation asset.

The community microgrid would reduce the amount of waste streaming into area landfills 90 percent if built as designed, according to feasibility study filed with the New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA), which is leading the $40 million NY Prize microgrid incentive program.

That’s in addition to enhancing the efficiency, security, reliability and resilience of utility grid and distributed electricity services for more than 600 National Grid commercial customers and approximately 1,700 residential homes.

“While most of the NY Prize projects include major critical facilities (e.g., police and fire stations, hospitals, etc.), the Syracuse microgrid also includes a larger number of smaller residential and commercial customers,” said John Saintcross, assistant director, NY Prize, NYSERDA. “Similar proposed NY Prize microgrid projects are in Rockville Centre and Freeport on Long Island.”

Costs and returns for the Syracuse microgrid

The Syracuse microgrid project team pegs initial design and planning costs at approximately $840,000. In terms of financial returns, they calculate the present value of the project’s capital costs at an estimated $6.18 million.

That would include the costs associated with installing a new 2-MW combined heat and power system and absorption chiller at the SUNY Upstate University Hospital-Community Campus (UUHCC), utility interconnection, upgrades to a distribution circuit at National Grid’s Rock Cut substation, and other system software and controls.

The present value of the variable costs of operating and maintaining the community microgrid are estimated at approximately $3.35 million, or $17/MWh. In addition, the project’s internal rate of return (IRR) comes in at 222 percent and its projected benefit-to cost-ratio at 2.6,,which essentially means the community microgrid is expected to return $2.6 for every $1 in costs.

“To say the Syracuse Community Microgrid Project is technically and financially feasible may be a significant understatement,” said Chris Carrick, who leads the project team for CNYRPDB.

He added: “Technology enhancements to the existing system, incorporation of existing and new DER [distributed energy resources] resources, financial and capital attraction models, and evaluation of benefits all suggest this project has the potential to provide significant benefits to the community while advancing the state’s clean energy goals.”

[clickToTweet tweet=”Syracuse #microgrid leverages waste-to-energy for positive return” quote=”Syracuse microgrid leverages waste-to-energy for positive return”]

Trash as a clean energy feedstock

National Grid, the utility that serves that area, is playing a key role on the project team, coordinating and providing electricity and gas system information, as well as guidance regarding regulatory, right-of-way, interconnection, engineering, rates, programs and other critical utility information to ensure electric system safety and reliability, according Virginia Limmiatis, National Grid spokesperson.

“While other microgrid projects may require the installation of new generation to achieve self-sufficiency, the Syracuse microgrid proposal uses an existing, large scale generator. This leverages an existing asset for microgrid utilization,” she said.

More broadly, project partners highlight the Syracuse Microgrid’s capacity to improve human and environmental health and quality by reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and other negative environmental impacts associated with conventional power generation, transmission and distribution. Those attributes fall right in line with the goals of the NY Prize and the state’s Reforming the Energy Vision (NY-REV), a revamping of energy rules to foster a decentralized grid.

“The goal of Governor Cuomo’s NY Prize initiative is to help communities become more resilient during power outages caused by extreme weather events and emergencies,” Saintcross added. “During an extended outage, the waste-to-energy facility is expected to have sufficient energy for these customers during a power outage lasting for up to seven days.

A catalog of prospective benefits

Serving as the project’s ‘anchor’ generation asset, Onondaga County Resource Recovery Authority’s (OCRRA) WTE facility only enhances these benefits, according to Carrick.

“The potential financial and business operation model provides a significantly enhanced revenue stream for OCRRA, which in turn provides a sustainable model of operation where additional landfills are not necessary and we have a cleaner, healthier community,” he said.

SUNY Upstate Hospital, for instance, experienced five power outages for the two utility feeds that serve the campus in 2012, six in 2013 and 10 in 2014, Carrick noted. Both feeder lines have failed twice in 50 years. Relying on emergency back-up generation, the hospital had to cut services some 50 percent.

In discussions with National Grid, the NYCRPDB-led project team understood that the hospital’s expansion plans could strain grid service further. “While it is difficult to quantify differed or avoided distribution capacity upgrades, the additional 2-MW CHP proposed at the hospital is aligned with the utility expansion plans and will help meet the projected load growth for the area,” Carrick said

Further on up the road

Looking ahead, advancing to stage three of the NY Prize competition would be a good sign that the Syracuse microgrid will actually be built, National Grid’s Limmiatis pointed out.

Twenty million in NY Prize funds are up for grabs in Stage 3 of the competition. “In addition, NY Green Bank is prepared to facilitate up to $50 million in financing assistance per project design,” NYSERDA’s Saintcross said.

Furthermore, “projects will need to demonstrate they can attract the scale of financing necessary to build and operate microgrids. Projects that can achieve this milestone will pave the way for the scaling of microgrid development, which is the ultimate goal of NY Prize,” Saintcross said.

Realizing NY-REV

The Syracuse Microgrid would make a substantial contribution to achieving NY-REV grid modernization goals, Carrick said.

“The microgrid will incorporate monitoring and control technology to allow other DERs to supply the load in the network without putting the grid operation at risk. This will create opportunities for customers on the microgrid to interact with the main grid, participate in the market, and define new streams of revenue and value,” he said.

Pursuant to these ends, the community microgrid project team has discussed options regarding interaction of the microgrid with regional transmission authority NY-ISO as well as National Grid. Carrick explained that the interaction with the surrounding grid across a Distribution System Platform (DSP) through market animation is a major aspect of REV.

“For instance, one possible innovation that may be considered within the REV framework is optimal economic operation of the resilient microgrid during blue sky days (i.e., during normal, non-emergency periods), by participation in the utility demand response programs and also NYISO’s energy, ancillary services, and capacity markets,” he said.

Snapshot of Syracuse South-Onondaga Microgrid

Partners: Central New York Regional Planning and Development Board, National Grid, GE Energy Consulting, Clough Harbour Associates, Couch White

Estimated cost: $840,000

IRR (internal rate of return): 222 percent

Cost/Benefit Ratio: 2.6

Objective: Enhance quality, reliability and resiliency of grid and distributed electricity services; lower energy costs, greenhouse gas emissions and environmental impacts; demonstrate the value of distribution automation, smart grid technologies and dynamic load management approaches to provide grid resiliency throughout New York State.

Scope: Three critical anchor facilities: SUNY Upstate University Hospital-Community Campus (“UUHCC”), Onondaga Community College (“OCC”), and Loretto Health and Rehabilitation Center (“Loretto”), as well as other public and private facilities, including a nursing home, a senior housing complex, a fire station, the Onondaga County consolidated 911 dispatch center, an elementary and middle school, public housing and apartment buildings, and approximately 2,000 residential and small commercial customers.

Energy Services: 24×7 baseload power generation and distribution sufficient to meet demand for more than 600 National Grid commercial customers and approximately 1,700 residential homes. Estimated seven-day emergency power microgrid generation and distribution upon conversion to island mode.

Power Generation: WTE for Onondaga County Resource Recovery Agency (“OCRRA”)

6-MW WTE; 9-MW natural gas-fired

Installation of a 2×1-MW combined cooling, heat and power plant paired with a 400-ton indirect fired absorption chiller located at UUHCC.

115-kV feeder line from UUHCC WTE to National Grid Rock Cut substation for grid-connected and microgrid island distribution.