California Energy Efficiency and Energy Storage Proposals: Bold Moves But Will They Take?

Share Button

California has on the table two bold new proposals to boost energy efficiency and energy storage. Which is more likely to see swift and non-controversial adoption?

The storage proposal mandates that California utilities bring to the grid a whopping 1.3 gigawatts (GW) of energy storage by the end of the decade. Earlier in the month, the California Public Utilities Commission released its long-awaited proposal for implementing the mandate, which has been the focus of discussions since 2010.

In spite of utilities’ interest in controlling this storage, the proposal says that third-party providers and customer-owned storage could play a role in meeting the mandate. Utilities may only own 50 percent of the storage to be acquired.

“The decision establishes a mechanism for storage projects to obtain financeable contracts. This is one of the main challenges for developing any storage project,” explained Elliot Hinds, a Los Angeles-based attorney for Akin Gump, who specializes in energy. The 1.3-GW goal is significant, but the proposal does grandfather in several already approved projects, including the 50 megawatts already mandated in Southern California Edison’s long-term plan for the West Los Angeles basin, he said.

By January 1, 2014, the three investor-owned utilities must file plans for their first energy storage solicitation.

The move is yet another win for the storage industry this year, said Hinds.

“A July FERC ruling requires independent system operators to open their tariffs to ancillary services that reward technologies that are faster, more accurate and more reliable, such as storage. These developments lift barriers to entry and take important steps toward creating viable market mechanisms that better recognize the true value that energy storage technologies can provide,” Hinds said.

While it may be a win for the industry, it won’t be so easy to implement, said Vincent DeVito, who served as U.S. Assistant Secretary of Energy for Policy and International Affairs and is a partner at Bowditch & Dewey, LLP in Boston. In fact, he said, it could become “vaporous” because it’s so difficult to achieve.

“The problem is that California is relying on utilities because that’s the monopoly that makes these investments into large-scale battery storage,” he said.

The state can require utilities to make this investment, but the utilities still have obligations to their shareholders, to provide reliable supplies, and to show that their investments are prudent, he said.

“A large-scale mandate makes it nearly impossible to check off all of those boxes. It’s unlikely that this will happen quickly,” he said. “There will be more time required to do due diligence. Just because the government puts mandates out, if they become uneconomical, then the mandates become vaporous because they are impossible to achieve.”

DeVito predicted that California’s storage mandate will see lots of moaning and groaning, followed by a smaller, public-private project. “It’s unlikely you’ll see utility investment until it proves out,” he said.

A small pilot would go a long way, said Rick Fioravanti, vice president, storage applications, DNV KEMA. “Internally, our team viewed this as the first time a utility commission set out to mandate storage procurement and opening the door to other states taking similar actions. For such a first time step, even if California agreed to 1 MW, we would view that as impactful. Though we don’t see California’s potential initiatives being the only action necessary to propel the storage market, we see the impact of California’s actions potentially having a greater impact of initiating other states into action more than so the procurement targets that were set – even though we acknowledge that the targets set by California are significant.”

While it’s unclear how or how quickly the energy storage mandate will be enacted, it is likely we’ll see quick adaption of California’s new energy efficiency incentive mechanism, said DeVito.

“This proposal won’t be as hard to push through – as long as the energy efficiency is viewed as supply, and people understand that it doesn’t mean they have to turn out the lights,” he said. “Ramping up energy efficiency is not unique. It only happens when it’s a sound business model.”

The mechanism, called the Efficiency Savings and Performance Incentive, rewards utilities for focusing on long-lived energy savings, as opposed to the cheapest savings. The longer-lived savings are generally achieved through deeper and more comprehensive energy upgrades, according to the National Resources Defense Council (NRDC). It should lead to innovative and comprehensive approaches to energy efficiency, said the NRDC.

For 2013 and 2014, California’s investor-owned utilities – Pacific Gas & Electric, Southern California Edison, San Diego Gas & Electric, and Southern California Gas – can earn rewards of up to $89 million total, for all the utilities.

The maximum reward is about one-quarter of one percent of consumers’ total annual cost for electricity and natural gas, and about two percent of the utilities’ recent pre-tax profits, according to the NRDC.

An NRDC summary can be found here:

It’s great news that California has the guts to propose such precedent-setting proposals, in spite of the potential for moaning and groaning. Once again, California takes the lead, a move that’s likely to inspire others to take risks and invest seriously in energy storage and energy efficiency.

Share Button


  1. Hi there just wanted to give you a quick heads up.
    The tet in your article seemm to be running off
    the screen in Chrome. I’m not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with web browser compatibility but I figured I’d post to let you know.
    The layout liok great though! Hope you get thhe problem resolved soon.

  2. If you really want a little gleam to set off the room, consider using satin finish paint for
    the trim. Perhaps each toilet flush is becoming a little slower, or the tub isn’t draining after a
    shower, or an ominous noise is emanating from the sink.
    Your time is valuable, so it doesn’t make much sense to spend all of it dealing with a plumbing problem.

  3. If you decide you must eat something totally not on your diet, you will be in effect doing
    a. Indeed, it has been found that men using HCG to lose weight have even better outcomes than female users in several instances.
    A typical HCG program involves combining a low calorie diet and HCG usage.

  4. Their information about the shipping, freight and flight facilities to move things into Oahu is better than those not living in these islands.
    Payers and health carriers seems to be caught up in the uncertainties surrounded around
    these health insurance exchanges and how the payers should align their health products and business
    structures to quickly and effectively realign themselves with the different state health
    insurance exchanges. show stocks where the average day range(100) is above 5%and Price is between $10 and $100and Average volume(30) is greater than 4000000and exchange is not amexadd column Average Volume(30)add column Average Day Range (30).

  5. When one hear the term plastic surgery, the first thing come into mind that it
    is related to a star (TV or movie actor) who trying to delay the effects of aging.

    Sometimes, our decisions could be clouded by pressure from our surroundings.
    Often fine dining and jewelry discounts are offered.

  6. You need to decide what your objective is before getting involved with social media marketing,
    which will result in greater success than if you
    were to go into it without any idea of why you’re really getting involved.

    If you are not producing successful social media campaigns then you
    are basically talking to a wall or to yourself. Generally speaking, if a website’s goal is to monetize content that
    is not original or high quality, then it is likely that the site
    has been targeted by Google.

  7. There are other studieѕ on how various oils affect the body such as, “Effects of lipid emulsions on lipid body formation and eicosanoid production by human peripheral blood mononuclear and polymorphonuclear cells. The enzymes in apple cider vinegar help regulate metabolism and reduce fluid retention. Eating: Start incorporating fresh food in your diet, foods such as fresh fruit fresh vegetables, these are packed with vitamins and minerals. Younger oils have more intense colors and fresher aroma and flavors. Now the question remains, which type of oil or fat do people need, or is the type of oil best fitted to the person’s genes and metabolism or health response to a particular diet or food combination. White from the Seventh-day Adventists have recommended vegetarianism. There are so many commercials advertising the new ‘wonder’ product, and when you check your e-mails you’re bound to see a banner ad for some kind of miracle skin care or weight loss product. Receiving regular adjustments can help to lower the overall stress placed on your body by affecting your autonomic nervous system. For girls whose acne is resulting from hormonal troubles, then starting the birth control regimen can be extremely effective inside fighting those zits. Some people may have a problem with swelling in their extremities or (edema) With enough Vitamin F, hair will just be healthier looking, and shiny.


  1. […] California Energy Efficiency and Energy Storage Proposals:… […]

  2. real estate search engine

    California Energy Efficiency and Energy Storage Proposals: Bold Moves


    California Energy Efficiency and Energy Storage Proposals: Bold Moves